lawskills
Google
search the Web search LawSkills.com
Did you know you can download our entire database for free?


Resources
[more] 

Georgia Caselaw:
Browse
Greatest Hits

Georgia Code: Browse

(external) Findlaw Georgia Law Resources


This site exists because of donors like you.

Thanks!


Lawskills.com Georgia Caselaw
PALMER v. THE STATE.
S90A0328.
SMITH, Presiding Justice.
OCGA 1665.116-6-5.1; constitutional question. Whitfield Superior Court. Before Judge Boyett.
The appellant, Robbie E. Palmer, was convicted of sexual assault against persons in custody under OCGA 16-6-5.1. We reverse. 1
The appellant was a juvenile probation officer in Whitfield County who was assigned to monitor a fourteen-year-old female probationer. Although Mr. Palmer had consensual sexual relations with the probationer on two occasions, he was only charged for an incident that occurred in January 1989.
The appellant contends that his conviction under OCGA 16-6-5.1 (b) should be reversed because the term "in the custody of the law," as applied in the statute, does not encompass persons placed on probation.
OCGA 16-6-5.1 (b) provides:
In interpreting statutes we are required to apply the ordinary signification "to all words, except words of art or words connected with a particular trade or subject matter. . . ." OCGA 1-3-1 (b). We note first that the title of the section as a whole is "Sexual assault against persons in custody." (Emphasis supplied.) Looking at other criminal statutes, we find only one that uses "custody" in a similar context. That statute, OCGA 16-10-52, prescribes penalties for escape, and presupposes actual imprisonment or detention. See Chandler v. State, 257 Ga. 775 (364 SE2d 273) (1988). Furthermore, the Probation Order which relegated the probationer to the court's supervision makes a distinction between "custody" and probation. The order states, "The probationer may be taken into custody and detained for violation of any condition of probation herein granted." The American Heritage Dictionary defines custody as, "2. the state of being kept or guarded; and 3. the state of being detained or held under guard, especially by the police." It is undisputed that the probationer was free to go about her normal activities subject to a court imposed curfew and her refraining from any illegal acts. It does not appear, applying the ordinary signification to the terms, that a person on probation is a person "in custody" or "in the custody of the law."
Criminal statutes must be construed strictly against the State and in favor of the accused. Cargile v. State, 194 Ga. 20 (20 SE2d 416) (1942). We agree with the appellant that the plain meaning of the phrase "in the custody of law" as incorporated in OCGA 16-6-5.1 does not encompass persons on probation.
Notes
1  The appellant was indicted on March 16, 1989. The Whitfield County jury returned its verdict of guilty on April 25, 1989. The appellant filed Notice of Appeal on April 28, 1989. The transcript of evidence was filed on October 20, 1989. The record was docketed in this Court on December 7, 1989. The case was argued on February 12, 1990.
2  Mr. Palmer's constitutional attack on this statute, which conferred jurisdiction in our
Jack O. Partain III, District Attorney, for appellee.
Kinney, Kemp, Pickell, Sponcler & Joiner, Marcus R. Morris, Cynthia N. Johnson, for appellant.
DECIDED JULY 12, 1990.
Saturday May 23 18:42 EDT


This site exists because of donors like you.

Thanks!


Valid HTML 4.0!

Valid CSS!





Home - Tour - Disclaimer - Privacy - Contact Us
Copyright © 2000,2002,2004 Lawskills.com