Did you know you can download our entire database for free?


Georgia Caselaw:
Greatest Hits

Georgia Code: Browse

(external) Findlaw Georgia Law Resources

This site exists because of donors like you.

Thanks! Georgia Caselaw
SHULMAN, Chief Judge.
Vehicular homicide, etc. Carroll Juvenile Court. Before Judge Brown.
T.E.D., a 14-year-old juvenile from South Carolina, was arrested by Georgia state troopers on August 10, 1982, after a high speed auto chase which resulted in the death of one man. Citations were issued to T.E.D. for various traffic offenses, assault with a motor vehicle, and vehicular homicide. A petition alleging delinquency was filed on August 13, and a hearing on the petition was held on August 20. The hearing was not reported and no findings were filed by the trial court. However, the parties agree that, on August 20, the trial court orally ordered that the child be returned to South Carolina. On August 23, the trial court revoked all orders entered in the case, reopened the case, and rescheduled the hearing for August 25. Pursuant to the juvenile's request, the hearing was continued. On August 27, a petition to transfer jurisdiction of the case to the superior court was filed and a hearing on that petition scheduled for September 1. The juvenile filed a plea in bar and objection to the transfer petition, which motion was denied at the September 1 hearing. Counsel for the juvenile then presented the court with a notice of appeal from the order denying the plea in bar and objection to the transfer and requested that the proceedings terminate with the filing of the notice of appeal. The request was denied, the transfer hearing was held, and an order transferring the juvenile to superior court to be tried for murder was entered. The juvenile has appealed from the denial of his plea in bar and objection to the transfer as well as the trial court's refusal to terminate the transfer hearing upon presentation of the notice of appeal.
The Juvenile Court Code of Georgia (OCGA Ch. 15-11 (Code Ann. Title 24A)) requires that a trial court set a date for a hearing on a petition alleging delinquency, which date "shall not be later than ten days after the filing of the petition" if the child is in detention. OCGA 15-11-26 (Code Ann. 24A-1701). Furthermore, unless waived by the juvenile or his representative, the proceedings must be recorded. OCGA 15-11-28 (b) (Code Ann. 24A-1801). After hearing the evidence on the petition, the trial court must "make and file its findings as to whether the acts ascribed to the child were committed by him." OCGA 15-11-33 (a) (Code Ann. 24A-2201). A dispositional hearing follows. OCGA 15-11-33 (b); 15-11-35 (Code Ann. 24A-2201; 24A-2302). An alternative to the foregoing proceedings is available in select cases if, prior to hearing the merits of the petition alleging delinquency, the juvenile court terminates its jurisdiction over the case by transferring it to the appropriate court for prosecution. OCGA 15-11-39 (Code Ann. 24A-2501).
The case now before us presents a situation in which a hearing on the petition alleging delinquency was timely held but was neither recorded nor followed by the making and filing of findings by the presiding judge. The state wishes to take advantage of these errors of the trial court by asserting that the errors completely voided the proceedings and placed the case in a posture where a petition alleging delinquency had been filed but no hearing held. We refuse to condone such a procedure or such a result. Since the parties agree that a hearing was held on August 20 and that the trial court issued an order during the hearing, and since we believe that both a transcript of the hearing and a written version of the trial court's order are material to the present appeal, we remand the case to the juvenile court with direction that the court reduce to writing its findings and conclusions of August 20 and that a transcript of the August 20 proceedings be prepared pursuant to OCGA 5-6-41 (g) (Code Ann. 6-805). The parties will have the right to renew the present appeal within 30 days of the entry of the mandated order by the trial court.
Arthur E. Mallory III, District Attorney, James M. Garcia, Assistant District Attorney, for appellee.
Ralph L. Van Pelt, for appellant.
Thursday May 21 19:48 EDT

This site exists because of donors like you.


Valid HTML 4.0!

Valid CSS!

Home - Tour - Disclaimer - Privacy - Contact Us
Copyright © 2000,2002,2004